Escape the Mystery Room
What to Expect
Escape the Mystery Room
All In Adventures offers thrilling, family-friendly escape room experiences in Middletown, NY, perfect for all ages. Step into immersive, themed games where you and your team will uncover clues, solve puzzles, and crack codes in a race against time. It's an unforgettable adventure ideal for birthdays, corporate events, and team-building, fostering teamwork and mental challenge. With private room bookings and a variety of games, it's a fantastic indoor activity for social bonding and unique entertainment.
What's Included
Good to Know
What People Are Saying
expected — in the best possible way. I went in thinking it would just be a fun little puzzle, but honestly, there were moments where I genuinely thought we were never getting out. The atmosphere was dark, suspenseful, and just creepy enough to make you second-guess every little sound. At one point, a clue triggered a noise behind us, and I swear my heart stopped. I wasn’t expecting to get scared like that, but it definitely added to the experience.
The puzzles were challenging but not impossible. Every time we solved one, we felt like geniuses… and every time we got stuck, we felt like we were doomed forever. The game master was great too — they gave hints just when we needed them without ruining the fun.
There was a moment near the end where we were all convinced we were trapped for good. We were yelling, scrambling, trying random things, and laughing at how panicked we got over a game. But somehow, we pulled it together and escaped with just minutes to spare.
Overall, this place delivered exactly what an escape room should: excitement, tension, laughter, and that rush of victory at the end. I’d definitely come back — even if I scream again.
Read More
Our host was fantastic and extremely helpful for not only the room but for our experience as well. The room was beautiful crafted with simple solves and hard problems. Definitely will be back again
Quick Facts
When & Where
New York, United States
1 Galleria Dr Suite 211, Middletown, NY 10941, USA
Booking & Cancellation
All In Adventures has a strict no-refunds or cancellations policy for bookings. However, customers can purchase Booking Cancellation Protection at checkout for an additional fee, which allows for a full refund (minus the 8% protection fee and any processing fees) if cancellation is necessary. Reservations can typically be rebooked online at least 48 hours in advance via the confirmation email. For rescheduling requests made within 48 hours of the reservation, the staff will endeavor to assist, but rebooking is not guaranteed.
People Also Ask
More about the place
Ratings & Reviews
expected — in the best possible way. I went in thinking it would just be a fun little puzzle, but honestly, there were moments where I genuinely thought we were never getting out. The atmosphere was dark, suspenseful, and just creepy enough to make you second-guess every little sound. At one point, a clue triggered a noise behind us, and I swear my heart stopped. I wasn’t expecting to get scared like that, but it definitely added to the experience. The puzzles were challenging but not impossible. Every time we solved one, we felt like geniuses… and every time we got stuck, we felt like we were doomed forever. The game master was great too — they gave hints just when we needed them without ruining the fun. There was a moment near the end where we were all convinced we were trapped for good. We were yelling, scrambling, trying random things, and laughing at how panicked we got over a game. But somehow, we pulled it together and escaped with just minutes to spare. Overall, this place delivered exactly what an escape room should: excitement, tension, laughter, and that rush of victory at the end. I’d definitely come back — even if I scream again.
Our host was fantastic and extremely helpful for not only the room but for our experience as well. The room was beautiful crafted with simple solves and hard problems. Definitely will be back again
Round 4 – Reel of Fortune 🎬🧩 Back again—and Escape the Mystery Room continues to impress! This time we dove into the Reel of Fortune room, and wow… what a ride! We were on a mission to recover a missing film reel to save our beloved aging theater and secure its place as a historical landmark. The puzzles were clever, immersive, and perfectly themed to the cinematic quest. As always, the staff was phenomenal—welcoming, attentive, and clearly passionate about making each visit memorable. They even remembered us from our last visit, which made the whole experience feel extra special. We solved it with time to spare and left buzzing with excitement. Since Hollywood Premiere isn’t available anymore, we’re thinking of revisiting some of the rooms we tried at the Palisades Mall—looks like the Middletown versions have a few twists of their own! If you haven’t tried Reel of Fortune yet, do yourself a favor and book it. It’s a blast!
We had a lot of fun as always! My family and I have come here a few times and it is always a great experience. The staff is very welcoming, friendly, and helpful! The games are fun and challenging to varying degrees but always interesting and well worth time and money spent. If you like a challenge and adventure, I highly recommend trying the Escape rooms here. We will be back again!
The staff was incredibly kind and helpful. We did the Black Ops room and it was so fun! The hints were lifesavers but genuinely was challenging while still being able to enjoy yourself. They offered half price if we did a second room and we took them up on that, scheduled to come back in November and we are so excited! 100% recommend.
You Might Also Like
More ways to destress and have fun in New York
Join our Newsletter
Get the latest stress-busting spots near you—no spam